A duotone photograph of a warm, dim Italian dining room with white-clothed tables and the soft glow of candles, rendered in deep black and rich red.

Classic Italian American

Roberto Paciullo's 5th restaurant, paying homage to classic Italian American dishes in the heart of the real Little Italy, Arthur Avenue.

View Menu

Welcome to Arthur Ave Fiasco

Located in the heart of Arthur Avenue's Little Italy, we serve classic Italian American dishes made fresh to order and cooked to perfection. From long-time favorites to family recipes, every plate is prepared with the care of a true neighborhood kitchen.

Meet the Chef

A duotone photograph of a chef's hands plating a dish in a busy kitchen, rendered in moody black and warm red tones.

Private Events & Parties

Hosting a private party or special gathering? Arthur Ave Fiasco offers event planning for celebrations of every size, with menus tailored to your occasion. Prefer to dine at home? Order online through your favorite delivery service.

Plan an Event Order Online